Thanks for your feedback. Sorry for the slow answer all available hobby time last two weeks have been going to preparing for a campaign day I'm hosting (nids vs imperials

).
atension wrote:
Some suggestions:
Gargoyles to (1)brood - They don't warrent (2) brood like raveners
Agreed.
atension wrote:
Reduce cost on Sky Swarm to 175 pts with an upgrade of two Crones/Harpies for 75 pts. Being an independant swarm they dont get any of the initative bonuses that come with synapse. A unit of 3 would be usless, one death and it would never recover.
I compared them to a formation of exocrines in the onachus list. They cost 175 points for three without synapse. The harpy has less range and lesser save, but does have skimmer, better total firepower and is way more mobile. i think they are about equal from a power persepctive.
I put them at a higer price because I think the mobility and skimmer/pop up possibility should come at a price.
However if testing shows them to be a waste, then I'm all for lowering to 175pts. Just want to be cautious with new stuff. It’s always easier to lower a price than increase it.
atension wrote:
Reduce the cost of the tyranocytes to 25 pts and the spaceship to 150 pts. Its a significant investment to opt for a drop force, 400 points for tyranocytes plus the spacecraft. With strategy rating of 1 the ship will get bumped out by every other race.
I based the price on the strike cruiser. Didn't think about taking the strategy rating into consideration. I agree that being strat 1 should be reflected in the price. Will lower the cost to 175 as a first step. Possibly to 150 later on.
50 pts seem to be what a lof lists pay for the drop pods. I'd rather increase the possible size for formations being dropped, than lowering the cost.
atension wrote:
Really like the terror swarm, thats what drew me to this list. Also I think the the mutable Heirophant is an excellent idea! The stats say 0-2 for the scything talons, are they replaced when you add other weapons? Also are you required to buy two other weapons? The wording is a little ambiguous.
I put 0-2 because you can replace them with the gigantic talons (and only by them).
You
have to take two shooting weapons in addition. I wanted to reflect the forgeworld modern hierophant.
atension wrote:
In the heirodule swarm it says "barbed och scythed"
That would be swedish for "and"
will amend that for all you english speakers
atension wrote:
The bio-artillary formation is a little tough. I mean i want to use biovors for their indirect fire cspabilities to prep formations for assault but like you said you cant really give them synapse. Feel they are a glass formation though. Was considering putting 4 in a core swarm and having that do the prep fire but it really is lacking in punch.
They're the same as in the onachus list. I have also found them to be rather situational in that list. They tend to die as soon as the enemy sneezes or even looks at them. My suggestion after thinking on the for a bit would be to give them a tyranid warrior stand.
atension wrote:
Id like to see a little more ranged shooting options so you arent as pigeon holed to an assault force. No suggestion on how though yet.
I think the list have more options than onachus as is, but perhaps not more shooting specific formations. Feel like that's ok though. Please let me know if you have any suggestions though.
atension wrote:
Any chance we could have this up on Army Forge?
Yeah I will do a file.
atension wrote:
Three types of carnifex might not be necessary, going to try them though.
No perhaps you're right. A scythed (onachus version) and a barbed might be enough. This is not ment as a tank list. Such a list would better warrant several versions. I went with three versions since that's what Leviathan has.