Does the seller have a repeating history of selling the same item? Does the seller have a history that looks kind of like this:
Warhammer Games Day ORC WARBOSS (#230123500968
Warhammer 40K CHAOS SQUATS (#230123501481)
WARHAMMER Limited Edition Beasts Of Chaos Standard (#230078623197)
WARHAMMER Rare Chaos Black Dwarf (#230078622264)
WARHAMMER Marauder Chaos Dwarfs (#230074775667)
Warhammer OOP 40K CHAOS DAEMONS STEED OF SLAANESH 3 (#320316563915)
Warhammer OOP 40K CHAOS DAEMONS DAEMONETTES OF SLAANESH (#320316563140)
Warhammer Limited Edition Malus on foot Rare Dark Elves (#320270661609)
Warhammer Unreleased Rare Dark Elves Mage & War Hydra (#320271053265)
Warhammer Games Day Limited 1998 Female IG Commisar LE (#320137235244)
Warhammer 40K LE IG Female Commisar OOP RARE Imperial G (#320079853243)
Warhammer Citadel Dwarf Dragonslayer & Dragon Head (#120153213258)
WARHAMMER 40K Games Day Female Commissar (#120474487657)
Warhammer Limited Edition MALUS DARKBLADE (#120454692982)
Warhammer Mordheim TOWN CRYER (#120454693567)
WARHAMMER Citadel Chaos Dwarf Whirlwind (#280386252346)
WARHAMMER Chaos Black Dwarf Figure (#280386251551)
Warhammer Chaos Dwarf TENDERIZER War Machine (#280087028515)
WARHAMMER 40K LTD ADEPTUS MECHANICUS SET (#280377611760)
Games Day 1998 Imperial Guard Female Commissar (#200235475298)
WARHAMMER Citadel Chaos Dwarf Tenderizer (#200340612454)
Sorry, I couldn't resist.
Seriously though, there is so much recast material out there that it could just be a resold recast from some other person or a shoddy original. I've seen some pretty sad originals when it comes to epic stuff.