Thanks all; I've updated the list with your ideas and a few more that came to me...
Spectrar Ghost wrote:
My main area of concern would be the number of activations you'd get; you could easily top 20. However they'd be fairly weak, so it might not be a huge deal.
That's intentional; The civilian formations are easily broken, and once broken, they'll have a hard time coming back. Also, I want it to be a viable strategy to keep the "uprising" elements back in reserve until turn 3, so the insurgent player would have to choose carefully when the uprising(s) occur. For that to work, it should be possible to place say 10 formations on the board and 5-10 in reserve.
Spectrar Ghost wrote:
Questions:
Why not simply have a 20 stand Insurgent Mob, and add 0-1 Revolutionary to the Upgrades? I also wonder why you've allowed variable numbers on so many things, and fixed the Snipers at 2, unlike the current NetEA IG lists.
I wanted the Revolutionary to be the center of the rebellion, and the BTS goal. I don't want the SC to sit hiding in some corner - Revolutionaries lead from the front! So, to emphasize that, it is a separate, beefier formation. I've also added more upgrade options to it in v.0.2, so it can actually be dangerous (and less easily killed).
I've added a bit more variety to the the specialist upgrade quantities; fixed formation sizes is a bit counter to the theme. Should I do the same for the Supporter formations?
Spectrar Ghost wrote:
Your Russes may be undercosted. 62.5-66.6 points each is the range they currently run. However in the armor-poor environment of this list, they will probably take more fire than usual...
Bumped the price a bit. Better?
Spectrar Ghost wrote:
Do you intend that Specialists be able to stack? Otherwise the standard disclaimer about each being taken only once should be added.
I actually did - variety is the spice of (revolutionary) life.
Spectrar Ghost wrote:
I'll probably never be able to run this in the absence of deciding to play a modern
GHQ Insurgent army elsewhere, but I'll try to put together some lists at least.
Thanks for the link - looks like good models for the purpose. I was considering just painting regular infantry in civilian (mixed) colors, but those Mujahedin and Toyotas are exactly what I was thinking about! Do you perchance have any scale comparison pictures that include this range?
GlynG wrote:
No time to comment properly now but I reckon you should include rules for suicide bomber insurgents in the list; like one-time attack stands / formations that are removed as casualties after attacking.
Agreed.
Fanatics and Saboteurs, and a Suicide rule, added. Something like that?
Ulrik wrote:
I'd have a look at the Mossinian Rebels for ideas. They're also rebel IG with large amounts of cheap infantry.
I like the Mossinians, too, but they "feel" like a regular army, just low-tech. I wanted something a little less ... organized.
netepic wrote:
PDF are probably a good start too

.
Err, PDF? What's that? Is there a "Planetary Defense Force" list?