Quote: (CyberShadow @ 21 Dec. 2008, 22:12 )
Miniatures... what do you think has not been executed as well as you would have liked? Also, what about the general style of the minis, any comments or feedback there?
Hmm.  Haven't noticed this topic before, but I might vent about something that's been on my mind, regarding the above quote.
Back when DRM and EW started up I was excited that there were new 6mm producers with a variety of Epic-compatible minis (and a full set of photos of the same!), and I was impressed by some of the white milliput vehicle 'greens' I saw.  I bought... not loads, but a fair amount.
Now?  Years later the novelty's worn off.  Whenever I pull the minis from the bottom of the lead pile, I'm cast a more critical eye and I'm less satisfied with them every time.  The reason, IMO, is why I lumped DRM and EW together in this post: I think Bob Naismith's having a laugh.
I'm probably the only person who thinks this, and I can list a few good reasons why:
- They're only 6mm minis.  Individual detail and quality isn't important at arm's length on a 6x4 board.
- The infantry, at least, are sculpted very quickly - I'd guess this drives down the cost for DRM. (Doug once told me how long Naismith takes to sculpt a single 6mm infantry figure.  I had to take a moment.)
- With GW's lack of support for SG and Epic, you take what alternative minis and games you can get.  Beggars can't be choosers.
To be honest, for me (very personally) the only one of those points with much merit is that speedy sculpting might keep the cost down for Doug and Tom.
I'm a stickler for good-quality sculpting, in any size and scale.  Not that 6mm has to have the same level of detail and artistry as 54mm (of course not); but IMO Bob Naismith's minis for DRM and EW are substandard.  They look rushed, blobby, and in places malformed.  Look at the Pax Arcadia Reg HQ in the store.  Look at the guy on the furthest right.  What's up with that?  The effect becomes worse in larger minis, approaching the size of 28mm minis, that should have more attention spent on them.  It's a problem GW has with certain Epic and Warmaster minis, e.g. larger daemons.
Take the Skyth for instance.  I was looking forward to these but I'm kind of disappointed.  Perhaps the process of taking photos of tiny, painted, based miniatures adds to the problem; but I have trouble making out more than the basic shape of the small infantry, and what I see looks like a bit of a mess, sorry.  Unfortunately I don't think the situation improves with the medium beasties.  To be blunt, they look like a random collection of soft, blobby details and textures gathered together into a rough animal or insectoid shape.
The vehicles are better, but there's a slight problem in design in that the detail looks more and more like the random discs and squares that they are.  The bigger problem is that details that are supposed to be symmetrical, aren't.  Bits are noticeably skewed, differently-positioned and even differently-sized.  The lance hoverscout, for instance, has two lateral guns.  One hugs tight to one side, but the other is out on it's own, attached only at the base.  Rushed in design and execution, I think.
In general design, most are good, but some give me headaches.  I've been looking at hammerjacks too long, and I'm not at all sure how the vorace moves it's legs.
I know some of GW's 6mm has an advantage in being designed and sculpted as 3-ups for plastic production, including some of the stuff that's now metal.  But while some of those are maybe
less detailed than DRM infantry, I think they look better.  Better proportions, or more careful execution, or something.  GW's new metals (Vehicles mostly.  Any new infantry?) are also sharper and less skewed.  Or compare
Max's Necrons to Bob's on-the-side infantry.  No comparison, in my opinion.
I just sold a bunch of DRM tanks and EW infantry in preparation for EW's modular tanks. I'm keeping my DRM industrial infantry (They are good proxies for skitarii, but I wouldn't mind sharper versions) but for IG proxies I'm not so sure I'd go with the current minis from either company.
Whew.  That was longer than I intended.  I know it'll hardly make much of an impact but hopefully I made
some sense.