Tactical Command http://www.tacticalwargames.net/taccmd/ |
|
Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread http://www.tacticalwargames.net/taccmd/viewtopic.php?f=14&t=25543 |
Page 1 of 2 |
Author: | primarch [ Tue Jul 09, 2013 5:33 pm ] |
Post subject: | Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
Hi! So as to not to have to go through all those post from the older thread I will summarize them here for further discussion. ![]() Titans with plasma reactors will roll to determine the amount of plasma available for that turn during the order phase. Pick one of the following methods to generate plasma Section I Plasma Generation Method 1 (Riquende Method ![]() Imperator: 1d6+6; minimum per turn is 7, average 9-10 Warlord: 1d6+3; minimum 4, average 5-6 Reaver: 1d6+2; minimum 3, average 4-5 Warhound: 1d6+1 minimum 2, average 3-4 Roll 2d6 and pick the highest roll (discard lowest). Option. For those whom like a little risk, rolling certain combinations of doubles may result in trouble. Double 1: Emergency reactor flush - Titan has just the 'bonus' plasma from the roll (so Warhound 1, Reaver 2, Warlord 3, Imperator 6). Double 6: Critical Overload - Every time the Titan uses a plasma counter roll a d6, on a 5+ the counter is put back into the plasma 'pool' rather than expended. At the end of the turn if the Titan has any plasma counters remaining roll once on the Reactor damage table and apply the result. Method 2 (Bissler's Revenge of d3 method! ![]() Warhound 2d3+1 (3-7 spread) Reaver 2d3+2 (4-8 spread) Warlord 2d3+3 (5-9 spread) Imperator 2d3+6 (8-12 spread) Method 3 (Dwarf Supreme's "get off my lawn you yung 'uns method ![]() No plasma generation is used. Instead an additional order called "repair" is added to the standard mix of order counters. Repair: This order applies to units with a hit location template capable of repair (most titans). While repairing the titan is a sitting duck. It cannot move or fire. However it may 2d6 for each damaged system and shield and pick the highest to see if it repairs. In addition to the 2d6 each die gets a +1 bonus to the roll. Note if the plasma reactor is down this must be rolled first before other systems can be attempted. I made this order MUCH better than the original AT rule to reflect the changes in the game since then. Mainly because losing one whole turn is a HUGE deal. So the order must be good enough to attempt it. If you use this method all other rules remain as core. Section II. Plasma Usage Plasma is used for a variety of things during a turn. Note that is you use a plasma generation method, the titan no longer gets an order counter. When it moves and fire is determined by its plasma expenditure. 1. Plasma is used for movement. If no plasma is used for movement the titan remains stationary. If ONE plasma counter is used the titan may move up to its normal advance move going FORWARD. It may also move up to HALF its advance move going BACKWARDS (fighting retreat). If TWO plasma counters are expended the titan can move up to its charge move FORWARD (you cannot charge moving backwards). Note it takes TWO counters for the titan to engage in close combat. 2. Plasma is used to activate fire control. The targeting systems require plasma to fire. It take ONE plasma counter to fire in the advanced phase and TWO counter to fire in the first fire phase. Note that these expenditures are in ADDITION to firing weapons. So at the bare minimum a titan requires THREE plasma to move, activate fire control and fire weapons. 3. Firing Weapons. All non plasma weapons may fire with the expenditure of ONE plasma counter. EACH one-shot missile requires a one time expenditure of ONE plasma counter. Plasma weapons require plasma for EACH shot depending on type: Basic charge costs ONE plasma. To hit 4+, save modifier -4 Overcharge costs TWO plasma. To hit 3+, save modifier -6 Range depends on the weapon used. Plasma bastgun 50cm CANNOT USE OVERCHARGE Plasma cannon 75cm Plasma destructor 100cm 4. Repair. Plasma determines how much energies goes to repair systems. ONE plasma counter gives basic repair functions for shield regeneration for that titan type (for example imperial titans would repair of 5+ for basic repair). TWO plasma counters for "code red" repair. This gives a +1 bonus to all repair and shield regeneration rolls. Optional. Over shield. The titan may expend ALL available plasma (may move its advance move to take cover, may not fire) to render itself invulnerable for one turn as the last shield does not fall when hit. However in the end phase roll on the reactor table for damage. Section III Hit location templates and weapon hard points 1. Hit location template changes. The hit location templates have been altered. The warlord will no longer have the reactor visible from the front arc, only the rear. It is replaced by "legs". Warhounds and Reavers will have the rear weapons location replaced by carapace. Thus the carapace is now visible on these titans. Use warlord carapace damage tables for them. 2. Imperial Titan Damage Tables. You can use either the original core ones based on d6's or the alternate ones using d10's. (Final Version pending DS changes) Weapons: roll D10 1-2: The weapon is slightly damaged. Until repaired there is a -1 penalty to To Hit rolls. 3-4: The weapon has been moderately damaged. Until repaired the number of hit dice or barrage points is halved, rounded up. 5-6: The weapon has been severely damaged. The weapon may not be fired until repaired. 7-8: The weapon has been destroyed and cannot be repaired. 9 : The weapon has been blown clean off the and scatters 2D6 cm in a random direction. Any units hit by the weapon must make a save or be destroyed. 10 : The weapon has been blown clean off, as above, but there is also a flashback to the Titan. Roll a D6 to see what was affected by the flashback: 1-2 : Carapace 3-4 : Reactor 5-6 : Head Then roll a D10 refer to the appropriate damage table. Legs: roll D10 1-2 : The leg is slightly damaged, reducing the Titan?s movement by 1/3. 3-4 : The leg is moderately damaged, forcing the Titan to walk with a limp. The Titan?s movement rate is halved. 5-6 : The leg is heavily damaged, as above, but also may not enter difficult terrain and may make only one 45 degree turn. 7-8 : The leg has suffered extensive damage and it is possible that it will give way if the Titan attempts to move. Roll a D6 is the ensuing repair phase, subtracting 2 from the roll if the Titan has charge orders, or 1 from the roll if it has advance orders. On a roll of 0 or less, the leg snaps and the Titan crashes to the ground. Determine Randomly which direction the Titan falls. Any vehicles or stands fallen are destroyed. 9 : The leg is crippled and may not be repaired. It may not move or turn for the rest of the game. 10 : The leg is blown apart and the Titan immediately crashes to the ground. Determine randomly which way the Titan falls. Any vehicles or stands landed on are destroyed. Reactor : roll D10 1-4 : The reactor has been damaged, reducing the output of plasma until repaired. The Titan's movement and CAF are reduced by half. Weapons have a -1 To Hit modifier and no plasma weapons may fire. 5-6 : The reactor has been breached and shuts down until repaired. The Titan is unable to move or fire. No other damage may be repaired until the reactor has been brought back on line. 7-8 : The reactor is breached and must be brought under control. The Titan may do nothing until the reactor has been repaired. In the next repair phase, roll a D10 and consult the following table: 1-3 : The reactor is partially repaired. See 1-4 result above. 4-6 : The reactor is completely repaired. The Titan resumes functioning. 7-8 : The breach has been contained, but the reactor shuts down completely. See 9 result below. 9-10: Meltdown! See 10 result below. 9 : The reactor has been heavily damaged. Automatic safeties kick to shut down the reactor, preventing a meltdown. The Titan grinds to halt, unable to move or fire. The reactor cannot be repaired for the remainder of the battle. The Titan is not destroyed, but is considered eliminated for VP purposes. 10 : The reactor is destroyed, resulting in a catastrophic meltdown which vaporizes the Titan. Remove the Titan and all units within 3D6 cms are automatically hit and must make an unmodified save. Units within void shields or power fields lose 1 void shield/power field. Carapace : roll D10 1-4 : The Void Shield Generator is mildly damaged. The VSG shuts down immediately, but there is a +1 modifier to the ensuing repair roll. 5-6 : The Void Shield Generator is moderately damaged and shuts down until repaired. 7-8 : The Void Shield Generator is heavily damaged. The VSG automatically shuts down and is irreparable for the rest of the game. 9 : The Void Shield Generator is severely damaged and in danger of overloading. Roll a D6 on a 4-6 the VSG is shutdown safely. On a 1-3 the VSG explodes as described below. 10 : The Void Shield Generator is crippled, overloads and explodes, causing catastrophic damage. The Titan is destroyed, but remains standing. All units within 2D6 cms are hit and must make an unmodified save. Any units with void shields or power fields lose one void shield/power field. Head : roll D10 1-2 : The Mind Impulse Unit is slightly damaged. Until repaired the Titan may only move or fire if you first roll 2+ on a D6. 3-4 : The Mind Impulse Unit is heavily damaged. Until repaired the Titan's CAF is halved and may only move or fire if you first roll 4+ on a D6. 5-6 : The shot punches through the bridge, killing crew members. The Titan's CAF is halved for the rest of the game. 7-8 : The shot rips through the head, causing major damage. The CAF is halved (halved again if already halved) and the Titan may only move or fire after rolling 4+ on a D6. 9 : The bridge is severely damaged, destroying the Mind Impulse Unit. The entire crew is killed by the feedback from the MIU. The Titan grinds to halt. Although the Titan remains standing, it is considered destroyed for VP purposes. 10 : The shot destroys the head and triggers catastrophic internal explosions. The Titan topples to the ground, destroying any vehicles or stands it lands on. Determine randomly which direction the Titan falls. 3. Weapon Hard points. There are three options available. a) Core. The restrictions to titan type and weapon points as described in Net Epic Gold core rules. b) Anything goes. No restrictions. Go crazy and see whom can design the better cheese.... ![]() c)Traditional. This is the most restrictive, limiting options to what the original AT era titans were allowed. Use the mighty Mattman Table! download/file.php?id=6988&mode=view Section IV MISC. Eldar and Slann are beyond the technological concerns of careful plasma monitoring. These titans do not follow plasma generation. They virtually behave as command units. Very dangerous. Chaos titans follow the same rules for imperial titans, except the Lord of battles and Slaneesh special titans are demon engines so get orders normally. Ork gargants do not have plasma reactors and are of lower technology, they receive orders normally as well. Please review for any omissions. Primarch |
Author: | Riquende [ Tue Jul 09, 2013 5:54 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
I can't see the restriction for the blastgun not being able to overcharge. |
Author: | primarch [ Tue Jul 09, 2013 6:32 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
Riquende wrote: I can't see the restriction for the blastgun not being able to overcharge. Hi! Added to original post, thanks! Primarch |
Author: | Mattman [ Thu Jul 11, 2013 12:27 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
I like method 1 for the plasma generation, will have to give it a try to get a real feel for it. Not sold on bringing D10s into the game for the critical hit tables, can we not just expand the current D6 lists? D10s also make penetrating weapons a lot worse. The weapon option table I created was just something I threw together so it is by no mean correct. I guess as part of these discussions (as in the other thread) we need to pin down the Reaver options as it is the tricky one, the Warhound and Warlord options are pretty easy (hardly any and all weapons, respectively). Matt |
Author: | primarch [ Thu Jul 11, 2013 12:33 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
Mattman wrote: I like method 1 for the plasma generation, will have to give it a try to get a real feel for it. Not sold on bringing D10s into the game for the critical hit tables, can we not just expand the current D6 lists? D10s also make penetrating weapons a lot worse. The weapon option table I created was just something I threw together so it is by no mean correct. I guess as part of these discussions (as in the other thread) we need to pin down the Reaver options as it is the tricky one, the Warhound and Warlord options are pretty easy (hardly any and all weapons, respectively). Matt Hi! How would you expand the d6 tables? D10 damage tables are accompanied by damage bonus increases (doubling them seems to work out). I like your more restrictive take on the reaver choices. I like that if you want a wide variety of choices you have to take a warlord. For wider selections use core or freeform. Primarch |
Author: | Dwarf Supreme [ Thu Jul 11, 2013 1:56 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
I present my alternate critical hit tables, 2d6 based. As usual, comments are welcomed. Weapons: roll 2D6 2-4: The weapon is slightly damaged. Until repaired there is a -1 penalty for To Hit rolls. If it's a Close Combat weapon, it can only be used on a D6 roll of 3-6. 5-6: The weapon has been moderately damaged. Until repaired the number of hit dice or barrage points is halved, rounded up. If the weapon has only one To Hit dice, there is -2 penalty for To Hit rolls. If it's a Close Combat weapon, it can only be used on a D6 roll of 5-6. 7: The weapon has been severely damaged. The weapon may not be fired or used in Close Combat until repaired. 8-9: The weapon has been destroyed and cannot be repaired. 10-11: The weapon has been blown clean off and scatters 2D6 cm in a random direction. Any units hit by the weapon must make a save or be destroyed. 12: The weapon has been blown clean off, as above, but there is also a flashback to the Titan. Roll a D6 to see what was affected by the flashback: 1-2: Carapace 3-4: Reactor 5-6: Head Then roll 2D6 refer to the appropriate damage table. Legs: roll 2D6 2-4: The leg is slightly damaged, reducing the Titan’s movement by 1/3. 5-6: The leg is moderately damaged, forcing the Titan to walk with a limp. The Titan’s movement rate is halved. 7: The leg is heavily damaged, as above, but also may not enter difficult terrain and may make only one 45 degree turn. 8-9: The leg has suffered extensive damage and it is possible that it will give way if the Titan attempts to move. Roll a D6 in the ensuing repair phase, subtracting 2 from the roll if the Titan has charge orders, or 1 from the roll if it has advance orders. On a roll of 0 or less, the leg snaps and the Titan crashes to the ground. Determine randomly which direction the Titan falls. Any vehicles or stands fallen on are destroyed. 10-11: The leg is crippled and may not be repaired. It may not move or turn for the rest of the game. 12: The leg is blown apart and the Titan immediately crashes to the ground. Determine randomly which way the Titan falls. Any vehicles or stands landed on are destroyed. Reactor: roll 2D6 2-6: The reactor has been damaged, reducing the output of plasma until repaired. The Titan's movement and CAF are reduced by half. Weapons have a -1 To Hit modifier and no plasma weapons may fire. 7: The reactor has been breached and shuts down until repaired. The Titan is unable to move or fire. No other damage may be repaired until the reactor has been brought back on line. 8-9: The reactor is breached and must be brought under control. The Titan may do nothing until the reactor has been repaired. In the next repair phase, roll 2D6 and consult the following table: 2-6: The reactor is partially repaired. See 2-6 result above. 7-8: The reactor is completely repaired. The Titan resumes functioning. 9-10: The breach has been contained, but the reactor shuts down completely. See 10-11 result below. 11-12: Meltdown! See 12 result below. 10-11: The reactor has been heavily damaged. Automatic safeties kick in to shut down the reactor, preventing a meltdown. The Titan grinds to halt, unable to move or fire. The reactor cannot be repaired for the remainder of the battle. The Titan is not destroyed, but is considered eliminated for VP purposes. 12: The reactor is destroyed, resulting in a catastrophic meltdown and cataclysmic destruction. Remove the Titan. All units within 3D6 cms are automatically hit and must make an unmodified save. Units with void shields or power fields lose 1 void shield/power field. Carapace: roll 2D6 2-6: The Void Shield Generator is mildly damaged. The VSG shuts down immediately, but there is a +1 modifier to the ensuing repair roll. 7: The Void Shield Generator is moderately damaged and shuts down until repaired. 8-9: The Void Shield Generator is heavily damaged. The VSG automatically shuts down and is irreparable for the rest of the game. 10-11: The Void Shield Generator is severely damaged and in danger of overloading. Roll a D6. On a 1-3 the VSG shuts down safely. On a 4-6 the VSG explodes as described below. 12: The Void Shield Generator is crippled, overloads and explodes, causing catastrophic damage. The Titan is destroyed, but remains standing. All units within 2D6 cms are hit and must make an unmodified save. Any units with void shields or power fields lose one void shield/power field. Head: roll 2D6 2-4: The Mind Impulse Unit is slightly damaged. Until repaired the Titan may only move or fire if you first roll 2+ on a D6. 5-6: The Mind Impulse Unit is heavily damaged. Until repaired the Titan's CAF is halved and may only move or fire if you first roll 4+ on a D6. 7: The shot punches through the bridge, killing crew members. The Titan's CAF is halved for the rest of the game. 8-9: The shot rips through the head, causing major damage. The CAF is halved (halved again if already halved) and the Titan may only move or fire after rolling 4+ on a D6. 10-11: The bridge is severely damaged, destroying the Mind Impulse Unit. The entire crew is killed by the feedback from the MIU. The Titan grinds to halt and may not function for the rest of the battle. Although the Titan remains standing, it is considered destroyed for VP purposes. 12: The shot destroys the head and triggers catastrophic internal explosions. The Titan topples to the ground, destroying any vehicles or stands it lands on. Determine randomly which direction the Titan falls. |
Author: | primarch [ Thu Jul 11, 2013 2:02 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
Hi! Sweet Thanks DS! So, which do you like better 2d6 or 1d10? You taking a stab at doing these for eldar/orks/chaos or you want me to take a stab extrapolating from your stuff? Did you update the d10 ones or should I use the original? Let me know and thanks again! Primarch |
Author: | The Bissler [ Thu Jul 11, 2013 2:06 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
primarch wrote: Hi! How would you expand the d6 tables? D10 damage tables are accompanied by damage bonus increases (doubling them seems to work out). I like your more restrictive take on the reaver choices. I like that if you want a wide variety of choices you have to take a warlord. For wider selections use core or freeform. Primarch I was about to say that I think Dwarf Supreme is working on changing the D10 tables to 2D6 tables but he got there first! Nice work DS! I agree about the Reaver choices also. Weapon-wise, I've always thought that the Reaver should be a halfway house between Warhounds and Warlords. Still, I enjoyed using a Quake Cannon on a Reaver last weekend! |
Author: | Dwarf Supreme [ Thu Jul 11, 2013 2:20 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
primarch wrote: Hi! Sweet Thanks DS! So, which do you like better 2d6 or 1d10? I like the d10 for the linear results and even percentages, but 2D6 does have appeal. One downside with 2D6 is that weapons with penetrating may be more lethal, because it might be easier to get the higher results. Only playtesting will really tell. Quote: You taking a stab at doing these for eldar/orks/chaos or you want me to take a stab extrapolating from your stuff? Did you update the d10 ones or should I use the original? The 2D6 tables are copies of the d10 version, with some rewording and proofreading. I tried to get the percentages as close as possible to the originals, except for the 12 result on all tables. With penetrating weapons and the +1 modifier for successive rolls on the table, I figured getting a 12 result won't be as rare as simply rolling box cars. I appreciate your offer, but I'd like to take a stab at the tables for Eldar, Orks and Chaos. You have enough going on with your alternate rules and taking pics of the primarchload. Besides, these tables were a labor of love and I'd like to be the one to see them to the end! ![]() Quote: Let me know and thanks again! Primarch You're welcome. As I said, it was a labor of love and my little part in giving back to the Epic community. ![]() |
Author: | The Bissler [ Thu Jul 11, 2013 2:25 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
For my money, the 2D6 chart would probably be the way to go, only because the rest of the game is played with D6. I hope you don't mind DS, but I have a few notes (in bold) about the Reactor hit table: Reactor: roll 2D6 2-6: The reactor has been damaged, reducing the output of plasma until repaired. The Titan's movement and CAF are reduced by half. Weapons have a -1 To Hit modifier and no plasma weapons may fire. In the Alternative Titan Rules we should address this result. Perhaps the number of Plasma counters generated each turn until repaired be halved? 7: The reactor has been breached and shuts down until repaired. The Titan is unable to move or fire. No other damage may be repaired until the reactor has been brought back on line. 8-9: The reactor is breached and must be brought under control. The Titan may do nothing until the reactor has been repaired. In the next repair phase, roll 2D6 and consult the following table: 2-6: The reactor is partially repaired. See 1-4 result above. Should read "See 2-6 result above"? 7-8: The reactor is completely repaired. The Titan resumes functioning.The chances of repairing all reactor damage used to be 50/50, it seems quite difficult to properly repair the reactor. 9-10: The breach has been contained, but the reactor shuts down completely. See 10-11 result below. 11-12: Meltdown! See 12 result below. I was thinking maybe the sequence should be changed here as high rolls are usually a good thing in Epic? I would suggest the following; 2-3 Meltdown! See 12 result below. 4-5 The breach has been contained, but the reactor shuts down completely. See 10-11 result below. 6-9 The reactor is partially repaired. See 2-6 result above. 10-12 The reactor is completely repaired. The Titan resumes functioning. 10-11: The reactor has been heavily damaged. Automatic safeties kick in to shut down the reactor, preventing a meltdown. The Titan grinds to halt, unable to move or fire. The reactor cannot be repaired for the remainder of the battle. The Titan is not destroyed, but is considered eliminated for VP purposes. 12: The reactor is destroyed, resulting in a catastrophic meltdown and cataclysmic destruction. Remove the Titan. All units within 3D6 cms are automatically hit and must make an unmodified save. Units with void shields or power fields lose 1 void shield/power field. I do really appreciate your hard work on this DS, hope you don't see my notes as being in any way a slight against your proposals! |
Author: | primarch [ Thu Jul 11, 2013 2:27 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
Dwarf Supreme wrote: primarch wrote: Hi! Sweet Thanks DS! So, which do you like better 2d6 or 1d10? I like the d10 for the linear results and even percentages, but 2D6 does have appeal. One downside with 2D6 is that weapons with penetrating may be more lethal, because it might be easier to get the higher results. Only playtesting will really tell. Quote: You taking a stab at doing these for eldar/orks/chaos or you want me to take a stab extrapolating from your stuff? Did you update the d10 ones or should I use the original? The 2D6 tables are copies of the d10 version, with some rewording and proofreading. I tried to get the percentages as close as possible to the originals, except for the 12 result on all tables. With penetrating weapons and the +1 modifier for successive rolls on the table, I figured getting a 12 result won't be as rare as simply rolling box cars. I appreciate your offer, but I'd like to take a stab at the tables for Eldar, Orks and Chaos. You have enough going on with your alternate rules and taking pics of the primarchload. Besides, these tables were a labor of love and I'd like to be the one to see them to the end! ![]() Quote: Let me know and thanks again! Primarch You're welcome. As I said, it was a labor of love and my little part in giving back to the Epic community. ![]() Hi! Thanks man! Looking forward to seeing them. ![]() Primarch |
Author: | Dwarf Supreme [ Thu Jul 11, 2013 2:42 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
The Bissler wrote: I hope you don't mind DS, but I have a few notes (in bold) about the Reactor hit table: I don't mind at all. Quote: In the Alternative Titan Rules we should address this result. Perhaps the number of Plasma counters generated each turn until repaired be halved? While I was updating my tables, it occurred to me that this would have to be tweaked to mesh with the plasma rules. Quote: 2-6: The reactor is partially repaired. See 1-4 result above. Should read "See 2-6 result above"? Fixed. That was a holdover from the d10 table I missed. Quote: 7-8: The reactor is completely repaired. The Titan resumes functioning.The chances of repairing all reactor damage used to be 50/50, it seems quite difficult to properly repair the reactor. Good point. We'll have to see it works out in actual game play. Quote: 11-12: Meltdown! See 12 result below. I was thinking maybe the sequence should be changed here as high rolls are usually a good thing in Epic? I would suggest the following; 2-3 Meltdown! See 12 result below. 4-5 The breach has been contained, but the reactor shuts down completely. See 10-11 result below. 6-9 The reactor is partially repaired. See 2-6 result above. 10-12 The reactor is completely repaired. The Titan resumes functioning. Higher results are good thing in epic, in this case a good thing for the shooting player! I'd rather keep it the way I have it, better to worse, to keep in line with the tables as a whole. Does that make sense? Quote: I do really appreciate your hard work on this DS, hope you don't see my notes as being in any way a slight against your proposals! No worries! I view your comments as constructive and not a slight in any way. |
Author: | The Bissler [ Thu Jul 11, 2013 2:58 am ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
Dwarf Supreme wrote: Higher results are good thing in epic, in this case a good thing for the shooting player! I'd rather keep it the way I have it, better to worse, to keep in line with the tables as a whole. Does that make sense? I know where you are coming from, but because this is a repair roll table I respectfully disagree. It would be the person whose Titan has shut down that would be rolling to repair, rather than the shooting player, therefore you would expect them to have to roll high to repair the damage. Anyway, just a thought! |
Author: | MagnusIlluminus [ Thu Jul 11, 2013 7:24 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
The Bissler wrote: Dwarf Supreme wrote: Higher results are good thing in epic, in this case a good thing for the shooting player! I'd rather keep it the way I have it, better to worse, to keep in line with the tables as a whole. Does that make sense? I know where you are coming from, but because this is a repair roll table I respectfully disagree. It would be the person whose Titan has shut down that would be rolling to repair, rather than the shooting player, therefore you would expect them to have to roll high to repair the damage. Anyway, just a thought! I agree with both of you, in a sense. Higher results are better for the player rolling the dice. Having higher be worse on the damage charts makes sense, as the shooter is rolling then and wants to inflict as much damage as possible. However, as the repair rolls are made by the owning player, higher should be better for him, rather than for whoever inflicted said damage. So my vote would be for the way that The Bissler rearranged it. |
Author: | primarch [ Thu Jul 11, 2013 8:28 pm ] |
Post subject: | Re: Alternate Titan Rules Summary thread |
MagnusIlluminus wrote: The Bissler wrote: Dwarf Supreme wrote: Higher results are good thing in epic, in this case a good thing for the shooting player! I'd rather keep it the way I have it, better to worse, to keep in line with the tables as a whole. Does that make sense? I know where you are coming from, but because this is a repair roll table I respectfully disagree. It would be the person whose Titan has shut down that would be rolling to repair, rather than the shooting player, therefore you would expect them to have to roll high to repair the damage. Anyway, just a thought! I agree with both of you, in a sense. Higher results are better for the player rolling the dice. Having higher be worse on the damage charts makes sense, as the shooter is rolling then and wants to inflict as much damage as possible. However, as the repair rolls are made by the owning player, higher should be better for him, rather than for whoever inflicted said damage. So my vote would be for the way that The Bissler rearranged it. Hi! I saw do them both! ![]() No worries it a simple matter of inverting the tables. Gotta keep the traditionalists happy too. ![]() Since its a separate book/PDF, I can stick in what ever needs to be done, so space is not a concern. Once DS, gets his stuff done I will collate it all into a PDF document for everyone's editing/comments. Once that is done I will look into a graphical layout for the actual book. ![]() Primarch |
Page 1 of 2 | All times are UTC [ DST ] |
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/ |