• Games
  • Miniatures
  • Library
Home » Blogs » CyberShadow's blog

User login

  • Request new password

Navigation

  • Tactical Command Forums
  • Blogs
  • Specialist Games
  • Recent content

Search form

Fall of the Thousand Sons, and the Resurrection

CyberShadow —12 August, 2011 - 13:25

So, I have recently picked up, read and finished the twinned Black Library 40K novels Prospero Burns and The Thousand Sons. And, I have to say, that I am a little disappointed. These books were sold as a pair, that you would read them one after the other and one would shed light on the events and happenings of the other, that the main story line would be told from both sides of the heresy story. Well, personally, I didnt find this to be true at all. For example, and without spoiling things in case you have not read them, there is a central character in Prospero Burns - which was the book that I read first - who is really the focus of the story. And yet, this character make zero appearance in Thousand Sons, despite the fact that it is implied that he would/should. Now.... again, treading carefully around spoilers as much as I can... it is also implied that an alternative version is present, but it was still unsatisfying. Dont get me wrong, the stories themselves are pretty good, but the two books are very different, with totally different writing styles, and they could easily just be unrelated. The fact that they are 'marketted' as two sides of the same coin is somewhat misleading.

Prospero Burns: This is an excellent science fiction book, but not an excellent Games Workshop book. If you are looking for the standard fare of 40K Marines striding through a barrage of gunfire that is deflected off the armour, to crack skulls three times each chapter and four times every fifth.... this is not the book for you. Its a slow burning read, but intriguing, even though it falls back on relying on some of the more worn-out Games Workshop staples - a twist that you simply cannot see coming as you are not given enough information, for example. Still, an enjoyable read.

Thousand Sons: This is a more traditional book, and is both better and not as good as Prospero Burns. On the plus side, it is better paced, and the characters are deeper and better developed. On the other hand, as a Horus Heresy book, it is only partially successful. For me, I want to read a HH book that focusses on the traitor legions, and be carried along. I want to watch their eventual turning and feel empathy for them, that their choices are understandable and rational, given the situation. This book almost accomplishes this, but not quite. I can follow the development of the Marine Chapter, but it never really completes the illusion of putting their side across, and making me feel that the choices that they made - although misguided - were understandable. Also, it suffers from the worst Games Workshop writing style issue, and the one that bugs me no end (even beyond poor editing, which both books suffer from, although not as badly as some BL reads) - chopping between story arcs! Honestly, I get so irritated by reading along with a story, only to get to a climax and find that it is the end of a chapter and the next page joins a totally different situation and character. I understand that this is a 'cliff hanger' and that I need to keep reading and will return to the initial arc soon, but cliff hangers only really work in television. In books, it is likely that I wont actually get back to the first story arc until I have picked up the book, put it down after the alternate story arc, and then picked it up a second time - usually a couple of days have passed by then. And, honestly, its lazy!

So, with those finished off, I am taking a break from novels right now - as life is a little busy at the moment and I dont get the time to sit down to read as much as I like. Hopefully, things will settle down again shortly. Instead, I am turning to a few comics. Right now, I have a stack of the IDW Transformers collections, and I am starting off with Last Stand of the Wreckers.

In a couple of weeks, however, a old title is reborn from DC. Resurrection Man is a line that I picked up the first half dozen or so issues in the late nineties, until Forbidden Planet London messed up my pull (not for the first time) and I dropped it. Its an interesting line, and the only one from DCs '52 rebooted' selection that I am interested in right now. And, the link back to the above books? Its co-written by Dan Abnett.

  • CyberShadow's blog
  • Log in to post comments

Comments

transformers

Submitted by Blackhorizon on 12 August, 2011 - 14:20
heh, taking a small snippet to reply. According tfarchive forum it seems that issue 22 of the ongoing transformer series from IDW is one of their best. From what I read the IDW comics are usually burned to the ground. Last stand of the wreckers being an exception. IDW has really bad writing when it comes to climaxes. Deus ex Machina gallores and so.
  • Log in to post comments
Light at the Horizon. Warp Rift Project Distant Darkness Eldar MMS GothiComp Hall of Fame http://www.tacticalwargames.net/taccmd/viewtopic.php?f=38&t=19176

IDW

Submitted by CyberShadow on 12 August, 2011 - 14:58
Yeah, well, they wont win any writing awards. But, they are not too bad, and certainly better than Dreamwave. At the end of the day, the stories are OK, the characters are actually fairly deep (you hear that, Mr Bay???) and the art is good. I dont keep up with the ongoing series, but I have the first three IDW collection hardbacks, and should pick up number four soon.
  • Log in to post comments

http://www.tacticalwargames.net/blogs/cybershadow - A brief look into my twisted world, including wargames and beyond.

Bayformers

Submitted by Blackhorizon on 12 August, 2011 - 19:09
Watch it. ;) I love Transformers movie one and three. Pt2 was lacking. I dislike the '86 cartoon movie for numerous reasons I appreciate the cartoons back then, most are pretty poor written and animated. I love the '80 comics. TF animated cartoon was actually funny. Dreamwave had one good miniserie, the rest indeed buggerz. Simun Furman & Andy Wildman are going to do TF issues 82-100 based on the '80 comics in 2012!
  • Log in to post comments
Light at the Horizon. Warp Rift Project Distant Darkness Eldar MMS GothiComp Hall of Fame http://www.tacticalwargames.net/taccmd/viewtopic.php?f=38&t=19176

Agreed

Submitted by CyberShadow on 12 August, 2011 - 19:28
I am pretty much with you on that. Movie 1 was disappointing at the time. But, after I had seen RotF, I suddenly really appreciated the first one! DotM (third movie) I think was my favourite. It still got panned by the 'TF community' - and they had some justification for that and I agree with some things. I hate the way Bay just lines up a group of Bots about a third way through a movie, doesnt explain how they got there properly, doesnt even mention their name most of the time (Jolt, Que/Wheeljack, Dino/Mirage, Grindor, Elita1... the list goes on) and then just kills them off. They might as well be wearing red shirts when they are introduced. That aside, DotM was actually an OK movie, not just an OK Transformers movie, but an OK movie. It reminded me of the bleakness of War of the Worlds in places, and it was the TF movie I had been waiting for since 2007. Like most people, I am nostalgic about the 86 cartoon series. I am watching them through again right now and I am on season three, with season four and then the Japanese G1 seasons to go (Headmasters!). Even I have to admit that its really hit and miss, with more misses than hits. Its not the worst of its kind, and there are some iconic moments, but an average episode doesnt hold up over time. I also love the old Marvel comics. I have every issue from 16 onwards stored in a box somewhere (UK versions). I also have the entire run on CD somewhere too... and I have to find that again. I stopped watching Animated after a while. It wasnt bad, I just wasnt that interested in it. I am currently watching Prime, though, and that is actually very good. Prime figures are being previewed now, and I am really looking forward to picking up a Soundwave, Evac, Megatron, Decepticon Vehicon and maybe Bulkhead and Arcee. I may pick up the Marvel reprint TPB. It depends. I cant actually remember what story arcs are being told in those episodes, although there are now two Classics books being released. It its the story arc with the Scraplets, I will definately grab it!
  • Log in to post comments

http://www.tacticalwargames.net/blogs/cybershadow - A brief look into my twisted world, including wargames and beyond.

Pages

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • next ›
  • last »

New forum posts

  • View first unread post Re: FWC Bootcamp 2012
    angelbarracks View the latest post
    Fri May 18, 2012 8:17 am
    Future War Commander
  • View first unread post Re: Armyforge Update (Online EA Force Creator...
    Mephiston View the latest post
    Fri May 18, 2012 8:06 am
    Epic Armageddon
  • View first unread post Re: Genestealer Cult List v0.4
    frogbear View the latest post
    Fri May 18, 2012 7:10 am
    NetEA Tyranids
  • View first unread post EA Bonesingers
    Matus View the latest post
    Fri May 18, 2012 6:47 am
    NetEA Eldar
  • View first unread post Re: Armyforge Update (Online EA Force Creator...
    adam77 View the latest post
    Fri May 18, 2012 2:04 am
    Epic Armageddon

NewBlogs

  • Space Hulk Timer

    I picked up third edition Space Hulk on pre-order from GW when it was released.

    Posted: 2 months 6 days ago
    CyberShadow
  • Dun-dun-dar-dun-da-dar-dun-da-dar!

    Product Alert - I found these in my local supermarket a couple of weeks ago.

    Posted: 2 months 2 weeks ago
    CyberShadow
  • I got the Squats!

    In preparation for a potential house move in the near future, I am attempting to get my stuff in order.

    Posted: 5 months 3 weeks ago
    CyberShadow
  • Site update

    Blogs

    Posted: 5 months 4 weeks ago
    CyberShadow
  • GothiComp 2011 Winners <p>[b] GOTHICOMP 2011 WINNERS:[/b] [color=#0000ff][size=12pt] Ship Category: [b]Jormugandr by Wintermans [/b] [img]http://www.tacticalwargames.n
    Posted: 8 months 2 weeks ago
    Blackhorizon

Pages

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • next ›
  • last »

Who's online

There are currently 0 users online.

Online forum users

Who is online In total there are 67 users online :: 8 registered, 0 hidden and 59 guests
Registered users: Anger Worm, Bing [Bot], Google [Bot], Google Feedfetcher, Mephiston, moocifer, TheAmazingAntman, ulric
  • Games
  • Miniatures
  • Library